* * *
And so I do.
I start with my attacking Teddy Lyons after the NCAA Final Four and my rationale for doing so. I move on to the Ry Strauss murder, the Jane Street Six, the recovery of the Vermeer, the monogrammed suitcase, Uncle Aldrich, Cousin Patricia, the Hut of Horrors, being attacked by Trey and Bobby Lyons. I talk for a full hour. Ema sits rapt through all of it. I confess that I am not this good a listener. I lose focus after a while and drift off. I get bored easily, and people see it on my face. Ema is the opposite. She is a great listener. I don’t know how much I planned to tell her—I do want to be honest because, well, why not?—but something in her mannerisms, in her eyes, in her body language, makes me more open than I intended.
Come to think of it, her mother is a bit like that.
When I finish, Ema asks, “Do you have paper and anything to write with?”
“In the rolling desk, why?”
She rises and heads toward it. “I want to go through all this again in more detail and write stuff down. It helps me to see it on paper.” She opens the rolling desk. When she spots the legal pads and the number-two pencils, her face lights up.
“Whoa, sweet,” Ema says, grabbing a pad and three exquisitely sharpened pencils. She heads back toward me and pulls up. “What?”
“Nothing.”
“Why are you smiling at me like a dork?”
“Am I?”
“Stop it, Win. It’s creepy.”
We go through it again. She takes notes, just like, well, you know. She tears off sheets. She slides them around the table. We lose track of time. Her mother calls. It’s getting late, Angelica says. She is ready to pick Ema up.
“Not now, Mom.”
I say, “Tell her I’ll get you home.”
Ema relays the message and hangs up. We continue. After a while, Ema says, “We need to have a more structured plan.”
“What do you have in mind?” I ask.
“Let’s talk about Ry Strauss first.”
I sit back and look at her.
“What?” she asks.
“You’ve done this before.”
Ema sits back too. And—I kid you not—she steeples her fingers.
“When Myron found his brother,” I say. “With your relationship with Mickey. I wasn’t really around for all that. I’m sorry about that.”
“Win?”
“Yes?”
“Let’s focus on you right now. We can deal with my past some other time.”
I hesitate, pulse a-flutter, but then I acquiesce. “Okay.”
“Back to Ry Strauss.”
“Okay.”
“We need to focus on who killed him.” Ema releases the finger-steeple and starts sorting through her notes. “The CCTV picked up Ry Strauss in the basement with a bald guy.”
“Yes.”
“And the FBI techs can’t get more details than that?”
“No. Bad pixels or something. Plus he kept his head down.”
Ema thinks about it. “Interesting he’d show us he’s bald.”
“Pardon?”
“Why not wear a baseball cap?” she asks. “Maybe he’s not really bald. Last year, at the talent show, a bunch of guys pretended they were the Blue Man Group.”
“Who?”
“Not important. But they bought these skin caps that make you look bald. So maybe it’s just a disguise. Maybe he wants us to look for someone bald.”
I think about that.
“Also”—Ema starts shuffling through the legal pad—“that barmaid from Malachy’s…”
“Kathleen,” I say.
Quick clarification: While I did tell Ema about my conversation with Kathleen in Central Park, I did not tell her about Kathleen returning with me to this very apartment. There is being honest—and there is being ew-gross.
“Right. Kathleen.” Ema has found the applicable section in her notes. “So Kathleen tells you that Ry was panicked about a robbery at his bank.”
“Correct.”
“Except we know that Ry didn’t have any money there. His money came from that LLC your grandmother—”
“Your great-grandmother,” I add.
“Hey.” Ema stops and smiles at me. “That’s right.”
I smile too.
“Anyway”—the smile drops and Ema is all business again—“let’s get back to your conversation with Kathleen. Ry, we know, never leaves his apartment except at night to meet Kathleen in the park, but suddenly he goes out in the middle of the day.”
“And,” I add, “on the day he gets murdered.”
“Exactly. So you”—Ema grabs a yellow sheet from the upper right-hand corner of the table—“use your contacts as Mr. Super-Rich Guy and visit the bank. The manager tells you that the robbers broke into safe deposit boxes.”
“Yes.”
“Which is odd, don’t you think?”
I shrug. “There are a lot of valuables in those boxes.”
“Yeah, I guess that could be it…” Ema says slowly.
“But?”
“But I have another theory.”
I sit back and spread my hands, indicating I would like her to continue.
“Ry Strauss rented out a safe deposit box at the bank, probably under a pseudonym.”
“That makes sense,” I say, not yet letting on that I had figured out that much already. “Any theories on what was in it?”
“Something that identified him in some way,” Ema says, tapping the pencil eraser against the tabletop. “Look, Ry Strauss probably used several identities over the years, agreed?”
“Agreed.”
“So he probably needed a safe place to keep the various IDs and, who knows, maybe his real passport and birth certificate too. You wouldn’t throw those things out.”
“No,” I say, “you wouldn’t.” I mull this over. “Are you saying that the bank robbers weren’t really after money—that they broke into those boxes because they wanted to find Ry Strauss?”
“Possible,” Ema says.
“But unlikely?”
“Unlikely,” Ema repeats. “I have another theory.”
I confess that I am enjoying this conversation tremendously. “I’m listening.”
“Your FBI mentor, PT.”
“What about him?”
Ema checks her phone for the time. “Is it too late to call him?”
“It’s never too late to call him. Tell me why.”
“PT said they caught one of the robbers.”
“Right.”
“Can you get to him?”
“Get to him?”
“Ask him questions,” Ema says. “Interrogate him. Can you use your Mr. Super-Rich Guy persona to get access to this bank robber?”
I frown. “I’ll pretend you didn’t ask.”
“Then that’s our first step, Win.” Her face breaks into a smile that reaches deep into my chest. “Call PT and set up the meet.”
CHAPTER 28
If you’d expect an FBI interrogation room to look like what you see on TV, you would be correct. We are in a tight windowless/airless room with a generic table in the middle. There are four generic metal chairs of which three are taken. I sit alone on one side of the table. Steve, the captured robber, and his attorney Fred are across from me.