Winter couldn’t help the ways she was writhing around on the hotel bed no matter how many times Luke or Chris growled at her to hold still, she still squirmed. “I can’t,” she cried out as they worked together to make her come—again. She had lost track of how many orgasms they had given her with their very skilled mouths, but that was probably because she had lost the ability to count at this point. Hell, she had just about forgotten her own name with the latest one, and when both guys finally stood from between her legs she wasn’t sure if she wanted to thank them or beg them for more. Luke had pushed Chris up against the wall and was kissing him like a starving man and she couldn’t help but prop herself up on some pillows and watch the show they were giving her.
She worried that she’d be jealous watching the two of them but she wasn’t at all. She was more turned on than anything else. Winter also worried that she wouldn’t fit between them but they had proven that theory incorrect too with the way she was literally wedged between her two alphas taking everything they wanted to give her. The three of them worked, just like Chris said they would, and she couldn’t think of a better way to ring in not only Christmas but her and Chris’s birthdays.
Luke ran his big hand down Chris’s body and wrapped it around his cock. Chris moaned into Luke’s mouth and she watched as they fought for control. It was raw, passionate, and so damn hot to watch the two of them together. With her, both guys were gentle, but with each other, they were demanding and even rough. Chris turned, pushing Luke’s back against the wall and he landed with a thud.
“Fuck,” Luke spat. He pulled Chris’s blond hair with his hand, almost as if trying to get a better angle to kiss him.
“I’m going to fuck your ass, Luke while you fuck our girl,” Chris ordered. Luke looked over to where she sat watching them and smiled, even giving her an outrageous wink and Winter giggled. She loved that Chris referred to her as “their girl”.
“He’s so much bossier now,” Luke said, referring back to their earlier conversation. Chris had certainly done his fair share of bossing her around these past few days and he was more in control, more confident than he usually seemed. Maybe it had to do with the fact that he was finally getting everything he ever wanted from the two of them. Or, he was just in his element and let loose for the first time—either way, she liked it. Bossy Chris was a hot turn-on.
“Slide to the edge of the bed, Winter,” Chris demanded. She did as he asked, knowing that she was going to like whatever he had planned.
Chris grabbed Luke’s hand and pulled him over to the bed, so he was standing between Winter’s spread legs. “He’s going to fuck you, Baby. You good with that?” Luke moaned and when he looked down at her, she could see in his beautiful brown eyes just how much he liked Chris’s idea.
“Yes,” Winter agreed knowing that Chris would want to make sure that she was on board with his plan. He had promised her that they wouldn’t do anything she didn’t want but so far, she wanted it all—both of them giving her so much pleasure.
Luke pulled her against his body, lining up his cock with her pussy and pushed inside of her. He was so big she needed a minute to adjust to his size. “Luke,” she cried out. He stilled inside of her and when she smiled and nodded up to him, letting him know that she was good, he pulled almost completely out of her body and pushed back in with one thrust. Winter moaned and arched her back as if begging him to play with her breasts. He took the hint and ran his hands up her body, making her nipples pucker and when he sucked her into his warm mouth, she nearly came around his cock.
“He’s big, isn’t he, Baby?” Chris asked. He was standing behind Luke with a tube of lube, getting his ass ready and she was fascinated by what he was doing. This world was so new to her that she wanted the watch every detail.
“Yes,” she stuttered. “I want to watch you with Luke,” she said.
Chris chuckled, “Next time, Honey. I want us all to get off and this is a perfect way to make that happen,” he promised. Chris pushed Luke down and wedged his big body between both him and Winter. Chris leaned over Luke’s body to give her a quick kiss and then kissed Luke. “Ready?” he asked, smoothing his hand down the side of Luke’s face.
“Yes,” Luke breathed. “Please,” he panted. She was so turned on by the whole scene she couldn’t imagine what it must feel like for Luke, but she wondered.
“Will you both take me like this?” she asked. Chris stilled behind Luke and closed his eyes and for just a minute Winter thought she had said something wrong.
“Give him a minute, Honey,” Luke said. “He’s trying not to come before he gets all the way in my ass. Our guy is probably trying to think of just about anything else other than one of us in your sweet pussy and the other in your sexy ass. Right, Chris?” he asked.
Chris groaned, “Not helping, man,” he said. Luke laughed, sending shock waves through her core and Winter gasped, squirming underneath them both.
“Fuck,” Luke swore.
“Yeah—now that’s called payback, smartass,” Chris chided. “Hold still, Honey so I can get in Luke’s ass, and then you can talk about us both taking you at the same time all you want to. That will be so fucking hot.” Chris pushed into Luke, thrusting Luke deeper into her body. It was so intimate the way the three of them were joined—like they were one unit working towards the same goal and God, her body was screaming for release.
“Shit, baby,” Chris shouted. He pumped into Luke with a new fury as Luke pushed deeper into her pussy. They found a rhythm that seemed to work and Winter felt as though she could personally fly they had her body so worked up. “Won’t last,” Chris grunted.
“Same,” Luke agreed. He reached a hand between his and Winter’s body’s to find her throbbing clit and with just a few strokes of his thumb, she soared like a caged bird set free for the first time.
The last thing she remembered was shouting out their names and then being surrounded by hot men and loving promises being whispered in her ear. Their night was perfect.
“Hey—it’s after midnight. Merry Christmas, Sweet Girl,” Chris whispered. “Merry Christmas, Babe,” he said to Luke.
“And happy birthday, you two,” Luke said, kissing her forehead.
“Merry Christmas,” she said around a yawn and snuggled into their bodies, drifting off into the darkness that was waiting for her.
Luke
Luke woke up early the next morning not sure where he was or what day it even was. Then, he realized that it was Christmas. The night before was the most magical Christmas Eve he had ever had and waking between Chris and Winter was more than he ever hoped it would be. He carefully climbed from the tangled mess of arms and legs to free himself from the bed, looking back down to find Chris and Winter cuddled up together. That was the way they always were—inseparable and those damn worries of being the third wheel suddenly played through his mind. He wanted them, that wasn’t the issue, but he worried that he was going to start needing them and what if they didn’t feel the same?
Last night was about sex and reconnecting after all these years and it was perfect but were they honestly thinking things through to the next step? Chris claimed that Winter would be on board with them adding a third but what if she changed her mind? What if she decided that she wanted Chris to herself? He knew that would leave him out in the cold and he wasn’t sure his heart could handle that kind of rejection again. He was good at being the one to walk away. That was how both his relationships with Winter and with Chris had ended. He told them that they weren’t enough for him—Winter because she wasn’t willing to go all the way with him and Chris because he wasn’t ready to come out of the closet but they were both his inadequacies, not theirs. He blamed them for not being enough when he was the one who wasn’t enough. Now, he was standing over them worrying that he’d never be enough for either of them or that he’d never be good for them.