A small part of my mind told me I needed to go and talk to my sister, find out what had upset her at school. But a bigger part rubbed its hands together in glee because if she was in a shitty mood, she was unlikely to come down until dinnertime. So I made no move to stop Lucas as he stripped my bra and panties away, leaving me standing totally naked in front of him.
"You're so damn beautiful, Hayden," he whispered, his voice hoarse as he ran his hands over my skin. His huge hands cupped my breasts, his fingers tugging at my nipples and making my back arch in response. He wet his lips at that, his eyes hungry as he continued touching my skin. When he reached my ass, he grabbed a firm handful of my butt cheeks, and I jerked.
His gaze shot back to my face, curious, and I just grinned. I wasn't going to tell him; he could just find out for himself. Which he did a moment later when he stroked his fingers down the length of my pussy and brushed the hard base of the butt plug.
"Babe, what..." He tilted his head to the side, curious, as his fingers explored.
I huffed a short laugh. "Cass," I said by way of explanation.
Lucas gave an understanding nod, then an impish grin. "Am I going to get in trouble here?"
I got the feeling he didn't give a shit if he did get in trouble. He definitely wasn't planning on stopping, at any rate.
"No." I shrugged and rocked my hips as he left the plug alone and sank two fingers into my pussy instead. "Or I don't think so. He just said not to take it out, not that I couldn't fuck you with it in."
Lucas dragged his lower lip through his teeth, his gaze thoughtful as he slowly teased me with his hand, making me shudder and rock against his palm. "Well," he murmured after a long pause. "Color me intrigued."
I grinned, fucking loving how Lucas had gone from virgin to one hundred in no time at all. He was all about new experiences, and I loved that about him.
"Well good," I replied. "But you have to let me do something first."
Reluctantly, I pushed his hand away before he could make me come too damn quick and sank to my knees in front of the couch where he sat. My eyes locked on his, I unbuckled his belt and trousers and freed his monster erection. My hand wrapped around it as he hissed a breath and leaned back to give me better access. He knew damn well what I wanted and was more than willing to facilitate.
Leaning in, I teased the tip of my tongue around his crown, still holding his gaze as I did and quietly getting off on the way his expression shifted. I stroked his shaft firmly, my fingertips not even meeting around his girth, then I closed my lips around his velvet-smooth head, sucking gently.
"Oh shit," Lucas cursed on a hard exhale as I took him deeper. "Hayden... babe..." he groaned as my hand moved in time with my mouth, making up for the distance I couldn't fit down my throat. I was getting better, though. Practice makes perfect and all that.
Lucas's hands went to my hair, his fingers pressing the back of my head as his hips jerked, forcing his dick deeper and lighting me up with intense arousal. There was just something about feeling like I was totally choking on cock that made my pussy flood.
After a couple of minutes, though, he pulled me up and gave me a desperate stare. "Babe, I need to feel that sweet pussy," he confessed, his voice rough.
Smirking my satisfaction and driving him wild, I climbed into his lap, balancing myself with my hands on his shoulders as he fisted his cock and lined up with my opening. Just as he started to sink into my warmth, the toy in my ass started vibrating, and I jolted like I'd just been electrocuted.
"What the fuck?" Lucas exclaimed as I stiffened and gasped.
"Cass!" I shouted, both enraged and goddamn tipping close to the edge of orgasm.
His dark chuckle echoed through the room, and I craned my neck to find him lurking in the shadows near the kitchen, the little toy remote in his hand. Lucas groaned a curse and gently bit my breast that was temptingly close to his mouth already.
"What'd I tell you about our game, Red?" Cass asked, sauntering closer with a smug tilt to his lips.
I rolled my eyes. "I told Lucas he couldn't take it out. What'd I do wrong?"
Cass shrugged. "Nothing. Just checking you remembered."
Seething at the interruption, I narrowed my eyes at him. "Well then, in that case..." I reached down to reposition Lucas's cock and sank onto him an inch. "Lucas and I were in the middle of something."
Cass's expression was so often unreadable, but not then. Nope, that one was all surprise as I held his gaze defiantly while spreading my knees wider and taking Lucas deeper into my cunt.
"Oh wow," Lucas murmured with a short chuckle, his hands tight on my waist. He could clearly feel the difference with the plug in my ass, just like I could. It was a tight fit, but not uncomfortable. Just... tight. Lucas lost his control a second later and held my hips firm as he bucked his own, slamming the rest of his cock into me and making me cry out.
For a brief moment, I totally forgot Cass was still standing there, then I felt a second pair of hands on my body, cupping my breasts as Lucas held my hips. A second mouth on my skin, kissing my shoulder as Lucas sucked my nipple. Fuck, yes.
Then I felt pressure on my ass as Cass tugged on the toy, and I leaned into Lucas harder. "Cass," I moaned as he played with the fucking thing, pulling it halfway out, then pushing it back in. Fucking me with it, even as Lucas's hips moved beneath me, his thrusts shallow.
"Hush, Red," Cass grunted, pulling the toy out completely, then squeezing more lube in its place. "I'd say it's a damn good thing you're letting me claim this ass first." His thick, hot tip pressed against my hole, and Lucas stilled beneath me.
"Oh yeah?" I shot back, breathless as fuck while he ever so slowly pushed inside. His dick was so much bigger than the plug I'd been wearing all day, but I knew how to take it. "Why's that?"
Cass gave a rough laugh, pushing in further and making me gasp. "By the looks of things, Gumdrop would have put you in the fucking hospital."
A burst of laughter escaped me at that, and Cass took the opportunity to push home.
"Holy fuck," I breathed, feeling both of them fully seated within me. It wasn't my first time... but it was for damn sure the first time I'd enjoyed having two dicks inside me at once. And make no mistake, I was thoroughly enjoying it. "Yes... shit, Saint..."
He hummed a contented sound, his hands skating up my body until he reached my face. With a strong hand on my jaw, he turned my face until he could kiss me roughly, then released me with a wink. "I've got you, Angel. You good down there, Gumdrop?"
"Fucking excellent," Lucas breathed, his hands finding my breasts once more and his teeth teasing my aching nipple.
Cass dropped his hand from my jaw to my throat, then kept it there as he started to move. He went slow at first, and Lucas followed suit. But gradually, carefully, they both picked up the pace. The harder Cass fucked my ass, the more his grip on my throat tightened. I was only just holding off on my orgasm, determined to drag this session out, but Cass wasn't letting me call the shots.
His other hand gripped a fistful of my hair, jerking my head back and lifting my whole body almost flush to his chest.
"Lucas," Cass growled, his breathing harsh in my ear. "Make our girl come. She's being stubborn."