They couldn’t believe their eyes. Nor their ears. Davien sat up in bed, staring at me like I was the eighth wonder of the world. Seth shifted on the couch, trying to discreetly readjust his crotch. Too late. I was perfectly aware of the erection he was trying to hide. I looked between the two of them, trying to decide who was more worthy of my attention. The truth was that I wanted them both at the same time. It wasn’t exactly possible, so the sooner I fucked one of them, the faster I’d get to fuck the other, too. I went over to Seth, on the couch. As he looked at me with wide eyes, I slowly straddled his lap.
I glanced at Davien and couldn’t help but chuckle. “Awww… You look like a kicked puppy. Come over here.”
Davien gulped. After a moment of hesitation, he complied.
I patted the couch. “Sit.”
The incubus sent the sphinx an annoyed glance, but sat down, nonetheless.
I took Seth’s face between my palms and forced him to look up at me. What was I going to do now? I wasn’t sure. Apparently, I was in control, because my two silly idiots were taking their sweet time wrapping their heads around what was happening.
“Suck,” I ordered Seth as I pushed my nipple into his mouth. He complied. As he started swirling his tongue around it, I turned to Davien. “Kiss me.”
He leaned in, and our lips met. He grabbed me by the back of my neck, pushed his tongue in my mouth, and I understood I would soon be in control no more. Seth cupped my other breast with his hand, then started switching between the two, kissing, sucking, nipping at my sensitive skin. He thrust his hips upward, rubbing his erection on my soaked pussy. My juices must have already destroyed his pants.
Davien proved to be more possessive than Seth. He pushed me off his lap and gently placed me on the floor. Seth growled in anger, but Davien knew how to play this game. He used his incubus powers to seduce me completely, while he sent telepathic signals to Seth to calm him down. I was sure this was happening because Seth seemed to change his mind about Davien and accept to go with the flow. He knelt on the floor, and as Davien took off his clothes, he started running his hands all over my body, taking in every inch of my skin.
“Oh,” I moaned. “Feels so nice.”
His eyes followed his hands. He squeezed my breasts, traced my stomach with his fingers, drew tiny circles around my navel. He cupped my shaved mound, and his index found its way between my wet folds. I parted my legs to give him better access, and he buried his finger inside me, making me quiver and want more. So much more.
I couldn’t take my eyes off Davien, though. As Seth fingered me slowly, I drank in the redhead’s perfect figure. His strong, wide chest was covered in freckles, just like his nose and cheeks. The curly hair between his thighs was just as red as the hair on his head. I licked my lips. His cock was fully hard, beads of precum dripping out of the slit. It wasn’t very long, but it was thick, and I knew he would fill me just right. When Davien lowered himself over me, Seth had to move back.
“Strip,” I ordered him. “And watch.”
He nodded. It was clear to me that he was under Davien’s spell because he was too compliant. On the one hand, the incubus was being so selfish and nasty! He was using his unique powers to influence both of us. But on the other hand, I was getting exactly what I wanted, so why complain? No, I wasn’t going to. I would just make sure that next time, Seth would be first.
I wrapped my legs around Davien’s waist as he slipped inside me easily. My pussy was soaked and ready. I received him inside my body eagerly, desperate for pleasure and release. I’d needed them both badly for a long time. Even that stupid bet they’d placed back in year one had served as a huge tease. I arched my back and dug my nails into Davien’s chest.
“Move already,” I demanded. “What are you waiting for?”
“I don’t want to…”
He was probably going to say “hurt you”, but I stopped him by pulling him in for a passionate kiss. He started moving faster, thrusting in and out of me, pushing both of us closer and closer to the edge. I felt like I was going to cum too soon, but what did it matter? I was almost desperate. We parted, and I glanced at Seth. He was naked, finally. As he watched Davien fuck me, he pumped his own cock slowly, teasingly, not wanting to finish before he had a chance to penetrate me. Well, I wanted him inside me, too, but there would be enough time for that. After what we did tonight, there would be no turning back. Davien and Seth would have to accept that if they wanted me, the only way to have me was to agree to share me. I slapped Seth’s hand away and replaced it with my own. His cock was long, and darker than his skin. Thick veins pulsated in my palm, promising infinite pleasure for when I was going to have him inside me.
I placed my other hand on Davien’s chest and pushed him away slightly, convincing him to slip out of me so we could change position. I moved onto my hands and knees, and as Davien penetrated me from behind, I took Seth’s cock in my mouth, sucking him slowly, tasting his precum like it was my favorite snack in the world. He moaned. My hair was in the way, so he gathered it in a thick ponytail that he held onto tightly.
I hadn’t given a blow job in a long time, and my jaw started aching pretty soon. Davien fucked me hard, and the sound of skin hitting skin filled the room. It was a good thing everyone was asleep, because the shifters and vampires in the MDC tower would have heard us for sure. With a little luck, we wouldn’t wake them up. I was so close. I bobbed my head, trying to take in as much of Seth’s cock as I could, but he was a little too big for me. I was sure he was going to fit just fine inside my pussy. My throat protested every time the engorged head hit the back of it. I started swallowing around him, and he grunted and moaned loudly. He thrust his hips forward, driving his cock as far as it would go, and soon enough, I felt his hot seed rushing down my throat. I whimpered around his cock, tears slipping from the corners of my eyes. I could barely breathe, and it felt… thrilling. Davien was pounding my pussy like his life depended on it, and Seth had just filled my mouth with his seed. I tried to swallow as much as I could. It felt so good to be dominated, possessed, controlled. It felt so good to be used for their pleasure. The thought that they were genuinely enjoying my body and had dreamed of having it for months, along with Davien’s intoxicating magic and thick cock, threw me over the edge. I released Seth’s cock and screamed, my walls clenching around the incubus. With a grunt, he came deep inside me, holding my hips in place with trembling hands. He didn’t let go of me as he shot string after string of hot cum right at the entrance of my womb.
And that was when it hit me.
My eyes went wide, and I scrambled to get away from them.
“Shit.”
“What happened?”
They were dazzled. Seth shook his head, then rubbed his temple as if he was getting a headache. When he looked up at Davien, pure anger filled his eyes. The incubus had stopped using his powers on him, as well as on me, and now Seth knew exactly what he’d done.
“Shit, shit, shit. We didn’t use protection!”
They ignored me. Seth grabbed Davien by the throat.
“Don’t ever do that again!”