“Tell me to stop,” he said.
Annalise shook her head. “I want it all.”
She sounded so needy, so desperate for his cock. He’d never been so turned on in his life. Gabe didn’t even know if he had the ability to go slow. It had been so long since he’d been with a woman, and it had been even longer since he’d been with a woman he actually cared about.
Annalise was so different. Did she even realize how much she meant to them? How crazy she made him feel? He doubted it.
With his gaze still locked on hers, he eased the tip of his cock down to her entrance. No condom. He didn’t want anything between them.
In the back of his mind, something niggled at him. Something important he should have remembered.
He tensed up, wanting to please her, to give her exactly what she begged for. He slammed balls deep inside her, her walls squeezing the shit out of his cock.
The moment he tore through Annalise’s pussy, he knew something was wrong. She tensed beneath him. The sound of her painful cry broke through the veil of pleasure that had crashed down around him.
She was in pain?
He’d caused that.
She shoved at his chest. He grabbed her hands and pinned them to the bed.
“What is it? What’s the matter?”
“Holy shit,” Vinny said.
“We should have known,” Archie said.
“Well, can you give me the fucking answer?” He didn’t have time for cryptic shit. Annalise was in pain, and he needed to figure out what to do to stop it.
“She’s a virgin,” Archie said.
The moment the word was said, Gabe just knew. There was no doubt. He’d even suspected it when she first moved in. She was so tight, and tears leaked out of her eyes.
Staring down at her, he couldn’t help but be amazed. “You’re a virgin?”
She nodded. It was a small motion, but one he caught without any trouble at all.
His cock had torn through her hymen.
She was a virgin.
His first ever one, and at that moment, Gabe knew she was going to be the only virgin he ever had. Annalise was his now, and he was never going to give her up. Not to anyone.
Her legs were circled his waist, gripping him tightly.
“How is that possible?” he asked. He let go of one of her wrists to stroke her face. Annalise had been given to them, and they were going to treasure her always.
****
Archie waited for the explosion to happen. There was no way Gabe was going to be happy with this revelation. Gabe didn’t handle shocking news well, but there was no anger, no sudden accusation. Just his best friend stroking Annalise’s cheek, so tenderly.
“I didn’t mean to hurt you.”
“It’s … I’ve never … this is all new.”
Damn it, they should have known. The innocence was not an act with Annalise. It was all real. It was why they had never seen her at bars in town, or out on dates, and he should have known.
He’d kept an eye on her for some time now, and he made it his business to know all kinds of information about women he wanted to fuck, and she had always been at the top of the list.
Finally getting Gabe to agree to a housekeeper had been a great victory in his mind.
Hands clenched at his sides, he watched Annalise as she turned her face toward Gabe’s palm.
“I wish you’d told me. I would have made it a lot better for you,” he said.
She smiled. “This is perfect. I’m sorry if I scared you.”
“I didn’t want to cause you pain.”
Archie watched as she gave a little wiggle. “No pain. Not anymore. Promise.”
Gabe chuckled, and at this, Archie looked over at Vinny, who had a goofy smile on his face. Archie figured he must have the same kind of look because that was exactly how he felt.
“Are you ready for me to fuck you now?” Gabe asked.
She nodded. “Yes. Please, yes.”
“So polite.”
Gabe tensed up as he eased out of her virgin pussy. Archie couldn’t look away as he watched his friend’s cock suddenly appear. He noticed the small smear of blood that showcased Annalise’s virgin state of just minutes ago.
Gabe eased in slowly, cautiously, riding her with more control than he’d be able to manage.
Annalise cried out, arching up.
Gabe knew what he was doing, and Archie didn’t want to look away as he began to change tempo, going fast, then slow, taking his time, making love to Annalise, and fucking her at the same time.
Archie took mental notes of everything she liked. Each thrust drove her higher. How she cried out slightly more when he swiveled his hips, hitting just the right spot deep inside her pussy.
Wrapping his fingers around his length, he started to work his cock, watching the scene before him. How fucking beautiful it was, seeing Annalise come apart.
Partway through, Gabe sat up, his dick still inside her. He licked two fingers, and placed them between her thighs, and this brought Annalise to life as she started to wriggle on Gabe’s cock.
Archie could no longer stand back, and he moved in closer, going to one of her heavy breasts and stroking the curve of her tit before putting his lips on her nipple.
“Fuck, yeah, do the same, Vinny. I bet she loves having all three men touching her. They wish they were me right now, Annalise. Their dicks are rock hard because they want to be inside you. Don’t you, boys?” Gabe said.
He and Vinny moaned their agreement. The sound loud enough for her to hear. He sucked her nipple into his mouth, and the temptation to bite down just a little bit was strong, but he held himself back, giving her time to get accustomed to having her tits sucked by two men.
She cried out, her hands going to their hair, sinking into the length.
“Fuck, I can feel her. She’s getting tighter.” Gabe growled as Annalise came. Archie knew he was already addicted to the sounds she made. They were soft, sweet, and drove him crazy.
He was ready to come, but he held himself back, counting to ten as Gabe began to rock inside her. Gentle at first, and then it was like his friend realized he was inside Annalise, and he began to fuck her, pounding into her pussy, making her scream and beg. Archie was so close. He had no choice but to stop or he was going to come right there.
Gabe’s breathing changed, and Archie lifted up, watching. Vinny did the same.
“I’m not going to last,” Gabe said.
Archie groaned and began to work his cock, feeling his own release starting to roll up through his body, to take control, and he was right. There was no stopping it.
The moment he came, his cum spilled out of the head, sending milky droplets onto Annalise’s pale skin.
Gabe wasn’t too far behind as he slammed deep inside Annalise.
Archie was very much aware their best friend hadn’t worn a condom, and seeing as moments ago she’d been a virgin, he doubted she was on birth control.
Vinny was the last one to join them, his cum joining Archie’s on her stomach.
They were all panting for breath. It was the only sound in the main bedroom. Archie stared down at Annalise and saw the flushness to her cheeks.
He couldn’t help but wonder what was going on inside her head.
They were silent. It took a while to recover their breath.
Gabe’s hands still gripped her hips tightly.
The weight of what they had all just done started to hit him. There were no regrets, at least for him. This was what he’d been hoping for. To Archie, this was a dream come true.