Finally, she whispers into the silence we’ve created together, “So you got quiet there. Everything okay?”
“I was just thinking the same exact thing.”
She looks up at me and nods. “Yeah, everything’s okay.”
“Good. I liked that, though.”
With a smile that lights up her beautiful blue eyes, she says, “I liked it too. It made me feel calm.”
“I thought maybe you might want to run there for a few seconds.”
Before she says another word, I know by the look in her eyes she did feel like running. But she didn’t, and that’s all that matters.
“I did, but I remembered what my therapist told me to do and made a list in my head of all the reasons I shouldn’t. Want to know what was on the top of that list?”
For a moment, a flash of doubt crosses my mind and I wonder if I actually do want to know the most important reason why she stayed. That passes, though, and I say, “Yeah.”
Taking my hand, she begins to walk us toward my bedroom as I wait for her to give me that reason. When we reach the doorway, she turns around and says, “The number one reason I had for not leaving is after last time, I’d be crazy not to sleep with you. Any man who can do what you did with your mouth has to be good in bed.”
I nod, smiling at how cute she is. “Well, I’m glad you liked my skills. I think you’re going to like what I can do with the rest of me too.”
“I’m sure I will.”
“So what was reason number two?” I ask while I begin to strip her out of her pink T-shirt and jeans shorts.
Looking up, I see her smiling at me when I tug her shorts down her legs. “I’ll tell you later.”
I don’t know why whatever this is between us feels so easy, like it’s right that she’s here and we’re about to sleep together. When I’ve been with other women, it’s never felt wrong but it didn’t feel like this.
Sweet. That’s what this feels. Sweet, like two people who make each other smile looking to find happiness in one another.
I can’t remember any time with a woman before that felt so comfortable like this.
As she steps out of her shorts and kicks them off to the side, I move to her T-shirt, pulling it over her head. She’s left standing in matching pink bra and panties, there in front of me with innocence in her blue eyes.
“Not that I wouldn’t do this, but I didn’t wear these thinking you and I were going to sleep together today. I wish I was that kind of woman, but I’m not that coordinated in the morning.”
Glancing up and down her body, I nod my approval. “Whatever reason you did it, I like it. Then again, I’d like you in seaweed underwear and a coconut bra, so keep that in mind.”
Hailey scrunches up her face like she just sucked on a lemon. “Seaweed underwear? That sounds gross. I think you might have just ripped me out of the mood.”
I wrap my arms around her and pull her against me. “Then it’s my job to get you back in the mood because there’s no way we’re wasting a fine coordinated underwear and bra day.”
She looks up at me like she’s studying my face for a long moment. “Are you always this cute?”
“Pro tip: men like to think they’re masculine and tough. Being called cute makes us worry we’re like puppies, and no guy wants to be like a puppy.”
While her fingers fumble with my zipper, she says, “Well, I’m sticking with cute. Funny, cute, and sexy. Any of those work for you, He-Man?”
“I hear women love funny guys. You make a girl laugh and boom! Her panties fall off. So I’ll take funny and definitely sexy.”
When she reaches inside my pants and palms my cock, I see a sly smile form on her lips. “Still thinking I’m just cute?”
Her tongue glides along her bottom lip and she reaches inside my underwear. The first touch of her hand on my skin makes me hard as a rock, and at this moment, I wouldn’t care if she liked me because I have straight teeth.
“Maybe not just cute. You do have some fine attributes. I’ve got one in my hand right now.”
She strokes it from base to tip, making my eyes roll back in my head. “I don’t think anyone’s every called my cock one of my fine attributes,” I croak out, barely able to form the words this feels so fucking good.
I watch in amazement as she lowers herself to the floor and kneels in front of me. “I figure since you did me last time, I should return the favor. You know, since your attribute is so fine and all.”
A second later, she wraps her pretty little mouth around my cock and her tongue hits the underside of the head to send me straight to heaven. Instinctively, I stuff my hands into her hair and tighten around the soft blond strands, but then I remember this is Hailey and not one of the usual women I’ve been known to sleep with.
When I release my hold, she looks up with confusion in her eyes. Leaning back, she eases my cock out of her mouth and asks, “Did I do something wrong?”
“No, not at all. Definitely not. I just didn’t want to…”
“You don’t have to treat me with kid gloves, Cade. I’m okay.”
“Trust me. You’re better than okay.”
Hailey smiles, and then she returns to sucking my cock. I watch, amazed at how she can be both so sweet and so good at giving head both at the same time. The combination excites me more than I ever imagined possible.
As much as I love the way her mouth feels on me, I want more for our first time together. Next time, she can finish me this way.
Tilting her head back gently, I smile down at her. “Time to switch positions.”
Again, she looks confused as I help her up. “Something’s definitely wrong, right?”
“No, definitely right, but I have something else in mind,” I say while I strip out of my clothes.
“Something else?”
A couple seconds later, I get those pretty pink panties and bra off and kiss her deep, tasting that tongue that made me feel like I’d died and gone to heaven. “Something else, as in you against this wall and me fucking you.”
Those innocent blue eyes seem to get a wicked twinkle in them now, and when I lift her up, she wraps her legs around my waist. She’s sexy and beautiful, and when she looks at me as I ease her down onto my cock, I’m not sure I can handle how sweet she is.
More times than I want to remember, fucking a woman was nothing but a physical act. A way for me to get off. A good time had by all, but that was it.
With Hailey, this feels different. More, like something was missing all those other times and now I just realize it.
I want something more than just getting off. I want what Hailey makes me feel right now.
Her lips brush the shell of my ear, and she moans softly when I ease out of her and fill her again. “Mmmm…that feels so good. I knew I wasn’t wrong about you being just as good at this as you were with your mouth.”
Kissing her neck, I say against her skin, “Hold on because you ain’t seen nothing yet.”
She rakes her fingernails across my shoulders, turning me on even more, and my body kicks into high gear. I thrust into her and she meets my need with her own, rolling her hips and taking all of me. Her body feels fucking incredible, like her cunt was made to fit my cock like a glove. We rock back and forth, in and out with a perfect rhythm like we’re in sync from the start.