Penny took a bite of her crab cake like she’d been starving. I smiled, remembering that when she got in the car she hadn’t realized I was taking her to dinner. She was probably used to the dining halls closing at 7, as well as dining hall food. I watched the way her lips circled around her fork. Since when had eating been so seductive?
"This is amazing,” she practically moaned as she took another huge bite.
I smiled. Isabella only ever ate salads. I literally couldn’t picture her eating anything else. I watched Penny take another bite. She really was refreshing. "What is it that you wanted to ask me?"
She finished chewing. "My roommate, Melissa. She can be rather, well, persistent. She always wants me to go out on the weekends and tries to get me to go on double dates and stuff."
"And?" I didn’t like where this was going.
"And what am I supposed to tell her?"
"That you're dating someone."
"But she'll want to know who it is."
"So tell her about me. Maybe leave off the professor part though." I smiled at her. One simple lie. How hard could it be to keep our secret?
"You want me to tell her I'm dating an older, wealthy, unbelievably handsome gentleman who is way out of my league?"
You’re the one out of my league. "And you'll want to say my name is James, not Professor Hunter. Which you should probably start doing in public as well." As much as I liked what her calling me Professor Hunter did to me.
"She won't believe a word of it."
"Hmmm. You'll have to mention that it's the best sex of your life as well. Maybe you can distract her with those details."
Her face started to flush again.
I was glad I wasn’t the only one thinking about how fantastic our sex had been. Was she thinking about reenacting it tonight? It was the only thing on my mind now.
"Thank you for dinner. That was one of the most amazing things I've ever put in my mouth."
Definitely not the only one with sex on my mind. "Certainly not the best, though. Do you need to be reminded?" One of the many benefits of a private room. And I’d already pictured having her in here. More times than I’d care to count. The one constant of my dreams was that Penny was always on the dessert menu.
She smiled at me and my dick hardened.
"I may need a refresher,” she said, a smile curling on the corner of her full lips.
This girl was fucking amazing. Flushed cheeks one moment and dirty words the next. I never knew what was going to come out of her mouth. My gaze dropped to her mouth. I needed those lips around my cock.
But Jerrod the cock-blocker walked back in with dessert menus. "Are either of you interested in dessert this evening?" He placed the menus down in front of us.
"I'd absolutely love some dessert," Penny said, but she was staring at me.
Jesus. "Could you give us a while to discuss our options?" I smiled politely at Jerrod, but what I really wanted was to tell him to get the hell out. He took forever to retreat. As soon as he closed the door, I stood up and pulled out her chair.
She started to get up.
"Sit back down,” I growled.
Her perfect ass immediately made contact with the fabric of the seat again. And she blinked up at me, daring me to make the next move.
"I already know what I want for dessert," I said and dropped to my knees. Every moment with her was like a fantasy come to life. I slid her lacy thong down her smooth thighs and spread her legs wide.
"But Jerrod will be back in just..."
I leaned down and swirled my tongue around her clit. Her words quickly turned into a moan. I sucked on it once more and let my tongue enter her wetness. So fucking sweet. Her delicious cunt had been haunting my dreams. One taste was never going to be enough. The taste of her. The little sounds her throat made as I feasted on her. No, we were never going to be a one-time thing.
Her hips rose, begging me to go deeper. I moved my mouth back to her clit and let my fingers enter her void.
She gasped.
"What were you saying, Penny? That you want me to stop?" I pulsed my fingers faster.
"No. Please, don't."
"Don't what?" She was so wet that I was able to easily slide one more finger in. It had been far too long since we’d been together. I loved her just like this. Eager and ready. Waiting for what only I could give her.
"Don't stop. Please don't stop," she moaned.
I moved my hand faster. She was seconds away from coming all over my fingers. But I wanted to taste her. I was just about to thrust my tongue back inside of her when the door creaked.
Such a cock-blocker. Jerrod was depriving me of my favorite taste in the world. I stood up and lifted my hands over my head like I was stretching. I added a yawn for effect.
Jerrod walked over to us. I wasn’t sure if he expected we were up to anything illicit, but if he got much closer, he’d see Penny’s panties dangling around her ankles.
She seemed to notice too and quickly tucked her feet under her chair.
"What is it that you decided you wanted again, Penny?" I asked her. I wanted her to respond like she did in class. Something suggestive and sexy as hell that only we’d understand. There was something about the game we were playing that made me hard as a rock. I’d always just taken what I wanted. I’d never had to sneak around. Who knew that being patient was so damn fun?
Her face flushed and her eyebrows pinched together as she looked up at me. It did not look like she was as eager to play along. But then she surprised me.
"I'm actually in the mood for something warm and salty." She raised an eyebrow at me.
I bit my lip, trying not to groan. Such a dirty girl. If Jerrod happened to look down, he’d see my erection pressing against my suit pants. Luckily he was the epitome of professionalism and his eyes remained on Penny.
"Well, we have salted caramel squares," he said. "If you'd like, we can heat them slightly. I'll have to ask the chef though. I'm not sure if they'll melt."
"I'd rather have something sweet," I said, my gaze dropping down to Penny’s lap.
"Well our lava cake is made from scratch and it is warm and sweet. Best of both worlds then."
"That sounds perfect," Penny said.
I needed Jerrod to leave the room right that second or I was going to cum in my pants instead of down Penny’s sweet throat. “We'll split the chocolate lava cake then.” I handed Jerrod the menus more forcefully than I meant to.
"Very good choice, sir.” He walked back out of the room.
I turned my attention back to Penny. I was going to devour every inch of her. "Your juicy cunt is the most amazing thing I've ever had in my mouth. And I'm not done with it yet." I got back down on my knees, grabbed her perfect ass, and pulled her closer. One long, slow, stroke with my tongue broke her. Fuck me. I let her orgasm wash over her and continued to slowly encircle her with my tongue. So sweet. I placed one gentle kiss on her clit and slid her panties back up her legs. I stood up and pulled her to her feet.
"We almost got caught,” she said breathlessly.
"We're not out of the clear yet." I needed her smart mouth around my cock before I exploded. I unzipped my pants and undid my boxers, letting my erection spring to life. "I still need to remind you what the best thing that's ever been in your mouth is."