Colleen shakes her head as a tear escapes. “I figured you forgot about me pretty quickly.”
“I never forgot you. I made choices I’m not proud of where women were concerned but it was because I didn’t care. They were pussy and nothing else. I knew I’d never fall in love with anyone like I had with you.”
Teyler licks a slow circle around her nipple then flicks as the bud hardens. “Did you breast fed her?”
“Yeah, can you tell by how saggy they are?”
Teyler bites down on a nipple and Colleen squeaks as the sensation floods her system. “What did I tell you about saying shit like that. Anytime I hear that shit, you’re getting punished.”
“Tey, I…”
“Try me, Coll. Go ahead. I have way more tricks up my sleeve. You want to see some?”
“Um…no?”
“That sounded like a question. You curious?”
“Maybe a little. I mean, I’ve read about alpha guys and their punishments.”
“And did you like them?”
“Yes, in theory. I’m not sure how much I’d like though if the things they did in those books were happening to me. Some of the ones I’ve read are pretty hardcore.”
Teyler smiles. Knowing that Colleen has a kinky side to her makes this more fun. “Well, then stop putting yourself down or you’ll find out.”
Colleen stares into Teyler’s eyes as his grow darker. Then he returns his tongue to her breasts and continues to lap at her nipples, biting down to nip at them every so often. “I asked because I want to know everything I missed, not because I think these perfect tits are anything but perfect.”
Teyler moves his body to perch over hers so he can continue his exploration.
Her stomach is next.
She tenses when she feels his fingers flick the snap of her jeans, but she raises her hips so he can lower them a bit. Then his tongue startles her and her hands go to his head when he licks a circle around her belly button. “I think you are so fucking sexy, baby. Stop pushing me away,” he demands, then his tongue dips inside and tickles her.
Colleen laughs, she can’t help herself.
“That’s my girl. Let go and enjoy this. Have fun with me like we used to. I’m not looking for imperfections, all I’m thinking about is how perfect you are to me and for me. If someone else thinks you’re anything less, great. One less asshole as competition.”
“I thought you liked competition?”
“On the court. Not with you. I thought I told you, you’re all mine.”
“I am, I always was.”
Teyler growls as he goes to the foot of the bed to stand and rip her jeans off her feet. After they’re off, he tugs her socks off too. She must have toed her shoes off when they entered her house on autopilot because she has no memory of how or when she lost them, nor does she care as Teyler sucks her big toe into his warm, wet mouth. He swirls his tongue around it and Colleen moans from the pleasure shooting from her foot to the rest of her body.
Her hips involuntarily leave the bed in a plea for what she needs and Teyler smiles up at her from between her legs.
“You look so perfect spread out for me to enjoy. Open your legs wider, baby. Fuck, I need to taste you again.”
Teyler lowers his mouth to her core and opens her with his thumbs. His tongue runs through her slick folds and Colleen’s back arches her body in half. “Teyler.” She sighs. “Please don’t stop this time.”
Teyler has no plans on stopping until she is thrashing under him and begging for mercy, screaming his name as she comes on his tongue.
He smiles into her pussy, then his eyes look up to see her accepting the pleasure he’s bringing to her deprived body.
Colleen looks like the sexiest thing he’s ever seen. Fuck those models and actresses with their breast implants and bird-thin bodies, Colleen is all woman and curves for him to sink himself into and he doesn’t plan to miss an inch of her as he worships her perfection.
“I’m close. Oh, my God!”
“That’s it, baby. Relax and come for me.”
Colleen finally lets go, she’s unable to hold back as Teyler sucks her clit into his mouth, his face moving side to side, causing a vibrating sensation to push her over the edge as she screams out his name.
Teyler licks her through her orgasm then eases her down with slow licks and swirls. “You taste so good and you’re so wet, Colleen. You ready for me?”
“Yes. But you have to promise me you’ll go slow, it’s been…oh, my God! This is going to hurt,” she says as Teyler releases his heavy erection into the palm of his hand and strokes himself as Colleen’s eyes grow glassy.
“Shh, relax. I didn’t hurt you when we were kids, I know what I’m doing. I’ll take it slow. But you have me so worked up, I’m not sure how long I can last. It’s been longer for me than I’m used to.”
“Okay, I’m ready. I need you inside me…now, Teyler. I need to feel you inside me again.”
“Give me a second to calm down and grab a condom.”
“I-I can’t get pregnant.”
Teyler looks at her with a quizzical stare.
“What? I thought you said you haven’t been with anyone. Why are you on the pill? That’s not healthy for you, Coll.”
“I’m not. I had some things, cysts and stuff, not a big deal. I don’t want to talk about it right now. I can’t get pregnant. I mean, if you don’t trust me after Taylor when I told you the same thing…”
“That was not your fault. I wore a rubber, it broke. That’s on me. I should have pulled out every time to be safe.”
“It’s not your fault, it’s mine. I probably missed a pill and didn’t realize. I…”
Teyler lowers his body atop Colleen’s, his muscular arms bracketing her upper torso. “Later, we’re going to talk. I don’t like hearing you were sick, even if it was a minimal thing, like you’re saying, which I don’t buy for a second. But, now, I need you, I need us, together again. Stop me if I’m hurting you, but, baby, I’ve never gone bare so, I’m apologizing now.”
Colleen nods. She wants to tell him to play that game Elliot Montgomery named his restaurant after and only give her his first inch, but she wants the pinch, she wants to feel him stretch and fill her.
Teyler leans down and captures her mouth, his tongue swiping over her lips and seeking entry. He kisses her until he feels the heat from her pussy seeking his cock out, her hips raising to find him. He leans back and grasps his cock, runs the head through her wetness then makes circles over her clit.
“Yes.” Colleen sighs. “It feels so good.”
“I’ve missed you so much. Your humor, your company, everything, baby. And I’ve missed this. Being inside you, fuck.” Teyler sighs as he pushes the head of his dick into her. “And bare. Fuck, you feel so good. So soft and wet, hot and so motherfucking tight. Let me in a little more.”
“Tey,” Colleen calls out as she stretches to accommodate him.
“I know, baby. You’re fucking tight. You feel so good. I’m serious about not lasting. I’ll be lucky to get all the way in before I come.”
Teyler works his cock into her slowly, inch by inch, and he pulls out and starts over each time he gains another. Holding back like this is killing him. He can feel his balls already pulling up into his body, his spine tingling with the pressure of his building climax and he hasn’t even started to thrust yet.