“Put your hands over your head and don’t bring them down.” He demands and I feel the rush of wetness at his words.
He grabs my thighs in his hands and spreads me further. He’s staring down into my pink folds and I move my hips in anticipation.
“Kailey.” He warns me, giving me a look that says he wants to punish me.
Fuck it, I want him to punish me, too.
I wiggle my hips again and nearly come when I hear his growl. Without any other warning, he flips me around and props my ass high up in the air. I feel his teeth first as he bites down on my right ass cheek but it’s the slap on the left that startles me. I cry out at the sting of both assaults and moan as the sensations spread over me.
“Did someone get herself in trouble?” I hear Cooper’s drawl from the doorway.
“Get over here and fill her mouth with something while I redden her ass.” Caine orders him.
Cooper, ever the willing participant, has his pants dropped and sits beside me on the couch. From the look of the tent he’s sporting, he’s ready to go.
“Kailey,” Caine grabs me by the hair and lifts me up. “I want to hear you gag on him. Am I clear?”
I want to, my mouth is watering and my eyes don’t leave Cooper’s as I lick my lips but I guess Caine was waiting for my answer. His grip in my hair tightens and he pulls me up roughly so my back hits his front.
“Is there any particular reason why you haven’t answered me yet?” His voice is low and dark. So very fucking dark.
“Sorry.” I whisper. “The answer is yes.”
“Good girl.” His breath washes over my cheek and I mewl in the aftermath of his gratification.
Yeah, it’s fucked up that I want this after everything I’ve been through, but I don’t give a fuck. I like it, no, I fucking love it.
He pushes me back down and my face lands roughly in Cooper’s lap. I grab the waistband of his boxers and pull them down. When his dick springs out, my mouth salivates, I want him so bad.
“I want to hear those gags.” Caine reminds me as I hear the clink of his belt coming undone.
Just the thought of being between the two of them used to throw me into an episode where I would be catatonic. But now… it’s something I look forward to. Caine and Cooper have rewired my brain and I no longer fear the feel of two men against me.
I lick the tip of Cooper’s cock and taste his salty precum. I love the feel and taste of him. I open my mouth and begin to slowly work my way down his length, bobbing my head to a rhythm I know he likes.
He curses under his breath and runs his fingers along my cheek. Where Caine is all rough and hard edges, Cooper is sweet and soft. The perfect balance.
I feel my legs being spread wider and then the head of Caine’s huge cock pushing its way inside me. The initial stretch always hurts no matter how prepared I am.
His hand grips into my hair and he pushes me down further onto Cooper’s cock, forcing me to gag. Cooper moans around my throat’s constriction as I struggle to relax.
“I told you to gag on it.” Caine grunts then slams himself all the way inside me.
The motion causes me to take Cooper even further in my throat and I’m gagging once again.
“That’s it.” Caine encourages. “Let me hear how badly you want to breathe.”
Then he’s lifting my head and groaning as I audibly suck in air. He begins a punishing rhythm and my moans are becoming louder. His hand slaps down onto my right cheek and then once again to the left. I don’t know how I ever lived without them.
“Suck his dick, then I want to hear you slurp his cum.”
His words have me clenching around his girth and the sounds of my arousal begins to grow louder throughout the room.
I do as he asks and take Cooper back into my mouth. With each of Caine’s forceful thrusts, Cooper’s cock is hitting the back of my throat. I reach my hand out and begin to massage his balls, his cock jerks in response.
“Sha,” Cooper’s voice is husky and filled with lust. “I’m going to...”
I feel his cock jerk and moan my approval as the first squirt of his cum hits my tongue.
“Slurp.” Caine growls and I do as he asks.
I slurp Cooper’s cock like a melting Popsicle on a hot summer day, the noise of my sucking and smacking lips spurring on Caine. I feel the gathering sensation in the bottom of my stomach and it slowly spreads to my legs and up my torso. I clench Caine’s dick and scream his name as I explode around him.
“Fuck.” Cooper groans. “I will never get enough of that.”
Caine pulls me up so my back is once again against his front and his mouth fuses to my neck. He hasn’t broken his rhythm yet and I scream when his teeth clamp down on my skin. This is his favourite way of branding me and making me his. I have teeth marks all over my body.
His strokes become erratic and I know he’s on the edge. I reach behind us both and grab his ass cheek, giving him a hard squeeze. He growls into my neck and pumps into me once more before spilling his load.
“Fuck.” He says through clenched teeth. “Why is this pussy so good?”
“I love you, too.” I say as I fall forward into Cooper’s arms.
Cooper plays with my hair as Caine goes to grab a towel. Again, this is our routine aftercare, same shit each time. Caine is rough and Cooper is sweet. He brings me comfort after I’ve been thoroughly ravished by Caine.
Caine carefully cleans me up and brings me my leggings. Then he pulls me up and gathers me in his lap on the couch. He smells like me and something I could only describe as home.
“I love you.” He whispers in my ear and I smile.
“Sha, I actually came here to talk to you about something.” Copper chuckles and reaches out to twist some of my hair around his finger. “Not that I’m complaining.”
I feel Caine’s chest moving as he laughs softly.
“What is it?” I ask him.
“Casey called me last night.” I sit up at those words and can’t help the jealousy that invades my senses.
“For what?” I don’t even sound like myself.
“Hold on,” he raises his hands. “Not for anything like that.” His mouth is turned up into a mischievous grin.
I know I really don’t have a right to feel this way. I’m currently in love with three different guys but shit, they were the ones to set this up.
“Spit it out.” I say with a huff.
“She hasn’t heard from Georgina since she disappeared with Brody.”
“And?” I roll my eyes.
“That’s strange.” Caine rumbles from underneath me. “Georgina likes to brag about all the extravagant things in her life, she’d be bragging her ass off if Brody took her somewhere for this long.”
“Have they ever been away for this long?” I ask them.
“Sometimes they would go for summer break and come back to school later but to be honest, this isn’t the best time for Brody to disappear.” Caine answers me.